OTTAWA – Canada’s latest federal budget proposes an extraordinary contradiction in housing policy.
Ottawa wants to extend the prohibition on foreign purchases of existing residential properties until January 2029, while exempting newly constructed homes. The stated objective is to attract foreign investment to stimulate construction while protecting Canadian homebuyers in the resale market.
But if Canadians cannot afford the new housing already being built, why is the government’s response to attract more foreign purchasers rather than address the underlying affordability problem?
Are we solving a housing shortage, or recapitalizing a development industry that built the wrong product, at the wrong price, for the wrong consumer?
Supply Without Effective Demand
Basic economics tells us that supply must be supported by effective demand: purchasers who can qualify for financing and afford the price.
Canada can simultaneously experience a shortage of affordable housing and an oversupply of expensive, investor-oriented condominiums.
Building more costly condominiums does not help a household that cannot qualify for the mortgage. Nor does converting those units to rentals create affordability when achievable rents cannot support their ownership costs.
We have confused speculative investment demand with sustainable housing demand.
The Presale Financing Cycle
Canada’s condominium development industry relies heavily on presales to secure construction financing. Lenders may require firm sale commitments approaching a minimum of 50% and more of proposed units, depending on project risk and market conditions.
These requirements legitimately protect lenders, but they also encourage developers to market units to investors anticipating rising prices.
Strong presales support financing, higher projected revenues and increasingly expensive development land.
The cycle reinforces itself until interest rates, incomes and achievable rents can no longer support the prices.
Developers are then left with unsold inventory, investors face losses, and lenders encounter increased financial exposure.
These are commercial investment risks. Why should government policy protect participants from the consequences of their own assumptions?
Foreign purchases of completed inventory may improve developer liquidity and repay construction loans. But they do not create additional housing.
This is not a direct taxpayer-funded bailout. Nevertheless, introducing another purchasing pool could support prices that would otherwise decline, delaying necessary market corrections.
Land Values, Density and Government Revenue
The problem extends beyond developers and lenders.
Development land values reflect anticipated selling prices, permissible density, construction costs and required returns.
When prices rise, developers can justify paying more for land. Additional density may create efficiencies, but those benefits can become capitalized into higher land prices rather than lower consumer costs.
Provincial and municipal governments also have financial interests in development activity.
British Columbia collects property transfer taxes tied to transaction values, along with an additional tax on certain foreign purchasers.
Municipalities collect development cost charges (DCCs), amenity charges, permit fees and property taxes.
DCCs are legally restricted to eligible infrastructure capital costs, not general operating revenue. Nevertheless, municipalities can become financially dependent on anticipated development activity to support infrastructure plans.
New development expands the property assessment base, but also creates ongoing service, maintenance and infrastructure replacement obligations.
Growth does not automatically pay for growth, and increased density does not automatically produce affordable housing.
The troubling reality is that developers, lenders, landowners and governments can all have financial incentives favouring continued construction, transactions and elevated property values.
Who represents the interests of households expected to pay for the finished homes?
Mortgage Financing Must Reflect Real Income
Canadian homebuyers must demonstrate sufficient income, acceptable debt-service ratios, adequate equity and the ability to withstand higher interest rates.
Foreign investors borrowing against Canadian residential property should face equally rigorous, independently verifiable and appropriately risk-adjusted underwriting standards.
Income, existing debts, down-payment sources, currency exposure and realistic rental cash flows must be established.
Non-resident investors should not receive taxpayer-supported mortgage advantages intended for eligible Canadian residents purchasing principal residences.
Foreign purchasers do not automatically receive preferential financing today, and some face stricter lending requirements.
The principle remains that speculative investment must stand on its own financial merits, without relying on anticipated appreciation or public financing support.
Who Ultimately Benefits?
Foreign capital can legitimately finance additional construction and support a healthy development industry. That benefit should not be dismissed.
But financing genuinely new supply is different from purchasing unsold condominiums to restore developer liquidity.
Before implementing this proposal, Ottawa should demonstrate how many additional homes will actually be constructed, whether prices and rents will become more affordable relative to Canadian incomes, and who captures the economic benefits.
It must also clarify which properties qualify as newly constructed.
Market corrections are uncomfortable, but they can reduce excessive land values and bring housing prices closer to purchasing power.
Governments should not prevent those adjustments merely to preserve development activity, financing arrangements or tax revenues.
We cannot make Canadian housing more affordable by continually finding new sources of investment capital to support prices Canadians cannot afford.
The ultimate measure of housing policy is not how much money developers, lenders or governments generate.
It is whether Canadians can afford to live in the homes being built and will they reflect a livable size and design versus more “dog crates” in the sky.
Tim Down, Principal, PacWest Commercial Real Estate Advisors
www.pacwestrealestate.ca




